Wednesday, June 22, 2011

Religion, art, and miracles

The inaugural World Atheist Convention was recently held in Dublin. I'm happy my country played host to the first such convention, small and all as it was (there were only about 350 attendees). Many people I admire, such as PZ Myers and Richard Dawkins spoke at the event, making my inability to attend all the more disappointing. It's a sign, surely, that atheism is on the rise. It is, in fact, the fastest growing religious category in the US. Majorities of Scandanavians don't believe in God. Sometimes, it seems as though religion is on the way out.

And then reality kicks in. As Christopher Hitchens points out, you need only look at placenames beginning with the letter B to find evidence of the negative impact of religion in the world. More rioting in Belfast, religious violence in Baghdad and continuing faith-based strife in Beiruit. Indeed, religion is something I long ago became extremely disillusioned with. I did, for a while, convince myself that I believed in Roman Catholicism (when I was around 13 - 14), and would attend mass with my grandparents as my irreligious parents would not go themselves. I don't think I ever really believed in a god, but I thought that if I attended mass, was heard in confession, took the eucharist and so forth, something would happen to change my mind. I was, unknowingly, following the advice of Blaise Pascal. Interestingly, Pascal's wager is commonly misrepresented by its critics. The philosopher and theologian does not, in fact, attempt to coax people into pretending they believe in order to trick God if he does indeed exist. Rather, his point is that non-believers should engage in religious rituals such as prayer and mass and so forth, and that eventually faith would come. And then you'll have all your bases covered, it seems. This is still silly, but it's not as ridiculous as it has been represented to be. I don't know what appeal religion held for me back then (I have a suspicion it was a childish fascination with the Church, its long, somewhat mysterious history, its rituals, etc.) but it certainly no longer illicits much sympathy at all in me. 

It seems to me as though there is no good action or feeling of sympathy that a religious person does or feels that cannot be accomplished by someone who is an unbeliever. This is why the claims of charity made by religious types is not compelling at all. A non-religious person is just as capable of charity as someone with faith. However, the most compelling argument against this is the idea of religious art. In fact, my viewing of the painting posted to the left, The Immaculate Conception by Diego Velaszquez was the impetus for this blog post. I'm fairly certain that Michaelango would be capable of frescoing the Sistine Chapel without religious faith, but I cannot honestly say that I am sure Velaszquez could paint something so intimately beautiful without actually having any faith in it. I cannot honestly say that about the poetry of John Donne (one good example being Batter My Heart), either. The question of religious art and it's moral worth is, to me, one of the few worthwhile questions still remaining about religion. That said, in a non-religious world, I wonder what artists, influenced by the natural world alone, would have drawn or painted or written. The beauty of science is much more substantial than the charms of superstition, I think.

But such a non-religious world is unimaginable. Humans, to a large degree, are seemingly hard-wired to believe in a deity. Certainly, religious devotion has been a constant in human history. Creation myths exist in pretty much every culture. In fact, the character of Jesus of Nazareth may just be an amalgamation of prior creation myths (certainly an interesting case for this position is put forward in the 2005 documentary The God That Wasn't There). I'd like to think that one day people will be enlightenend enough to let go of religion. It is an extremely weak first attempt at explaining the world. It is the first attempt at philosophy, science, medicine, astronomy, etc., and that's why it ought to be taken seriously and why I enjoy arguments and debates on the subject. Some may fear a hyper-rationalistic society, but I'll cross that bridge if ever we get there.

Finally, I want to bring to your attention this clip of Christopher Hitchens annihilating a religious apologist on the idea of miracles. This is absolutely fantastic stuff, and demonstrates the abject ridiculousness of religious miracle claims. My favourite point concerns the commonplace nature of ressurection in the Bible, it's something of a banality according to the gospels, which makes the claims about Jesus's ressurrection proving his divinity seems a bit silly altogether. It's a great watch!

Tipp's new casino


I'm all in favour of the new casino resort in Two Mile Borris, which is just outside of Thurles, the town I call home. I think the criticisms of the project are entirely unconvincing. Broadsheet.ie referred to it as a "stunningly tasteless, hubristic metaphor". This attempt at associating the casino with the reckless gambling of The Bankers is cheap and absurd, however light-hearted it may be. Without this kind of large-scale investment, how will we pull ourselves out of the mess we're in, anyway?

This kind of venture represents Ireland's future. Manufacturing will never survive here, and so that focus will shift to the service industry. Some have complained that it means more "low grade, minimum wage jobs" (as a commenter on Broadsheet remarked). This might be true, but those kind of jobs already exist. Many people are glad of them, many people will be glad of the employment opportunities offered by this new project. 

There are concerns about the effect this may have on culture and environment, too, but all of them seem wildly overstated.  People already gamble every single day in this country, online, in bookmakers or in the small-size casinos in some of the bigger cities. It's not as though there is no gambling culture as things stand. The notion that this behaviour somehow becomes sleazy or corrupting only when it takes place in a Vegas-style casino is nonsense. In terms of visual pollution, the buildings that comprise the casino are not at all tacky, and even the White House replica looks attractive and is actually a tribute to it's designer, James Hoban, who was born and raised in Kilkenny, rather than a gaudy imitation. 

Worries about the riskiness of this venture are more reasonable, but I think the fact that the site is situtated equidistant from all the major cities in the Republic is compelling evidence that this resort will attract the necessary number of consumers. Many tourists already come to Tipperary to visit the famous Rock of Cashel, anyway. Overall, I'm just very excited. Things like this don't really happen in Tipperary. Most of the people here I talk to, from my 20 year old friends to my elderly grandparents are also very excited. This is good news