Showing posts with label david norris. Show all posts
Showing posts with label david norris. Show all posts

Monday, December 27, 2010

Does David Norris represent Irish attitudes on foreign policy?

“Behold the Tolerant Irish!”, so the headlines around the world will read if David Norris is elected president in 2011. At least, that's what he wants you to think. He believes that media around the world will proclaim Ireland to be an impressively accepting society after his election as the first ever openly gay head of state. Norris believes that the 'good press' generated by his election will somehow create the political capital necessary to secure the best possible reputation for this country. This is not just some off the cuff remark by Norris. He has stated it over and over again – in interviews on television, radio, and recently in his address to DCU students. The fact that he has made the novelty factor of his sexuality an important point in his campaign is typically inapropriate and characteristically frivolous. Furthermore, I believe that Mr. Norris is wrong in this prediction. The headlines in the US, for example, will not glorify Irish tolerance, but will focus on the vicious anti-American sentiments that litter his political career.
In 2005, Norris declared the United States government to be a “criminal regime”, spreading its' “plague” all over the world. He made these comments on the floor of the Seanad, in his capacity as a senator. I'm fairly certain that this kind of animus directed at the American people (those who elect this “criminal regime”) won't go down so well. What's more, his sympathy for terrorist organisations like Hamas is worrying. While the American governement, which runs a free and tolerant society, is “criminal” in Norris' view, Hamas, an organisation that murders members of the oppostion, seeks the destruction of Israel (and, as a matter of fact, the execution of all homosexuals) is the “legitimate government” of Gaza. Most Irish people, I would imagine, are not supportive of organisations that wish to see the Jewish state in ruins. Most people would describe Hamas' very existance as being shameful. Not David Norris, though. For him, the only thing that is “shameful” is the EU's boycott of this extremist organisation. Why someone with such a strong record on defending civil liberties and standing up for human rights in this country has an ounce of sympathy for reactionary extremists is baffling.

When he visited DCU last year, I asked David Norris about his anti-American track record, and pressed him on whether or not he still stands by his assertion of the criminality of the Bush administration. "Yes" he replied. He went on, in typical unseriousness, to say he couldn't possibly be anti-American because he liked Bugs Bunny. Then he asked me about Guantanamo Bay. using it as some kind proof of Bush's criminal status. President Obama has kept Guantanamo Bay open, and has resumed military tribunals there. In fact, Obama has virtually continued all of the Bush anti-terror policies. But Norris remains silent on this, instead showering Obama with praise. There is a blatent inconsistency here, one that highlights Norris' childishness and naivity on matters of foreign policy. Bush is proud of America's foreign policy, so he is hated. Obama offers petty platitudes in the form of apologies and regret for Iraq, but continues all of Bush's policies anyway, and he is adored. Is this really the behaviour of a man of principles when it comes to these important issues? Of course not.

I realise the presidency will not give David Norris an opportunity to enact any policies or even to impact on political discourse in any meaningful way. Even if it did, Ireland is a tiny country, our foreign policy largely does not matter. It is true, however, that the presidency is entirely symbolic (the constitution doesn't even nominally vest any executive power in the president). Given that the presidency is supposed to be representative of Irish attitudes and values to the rest of the world, the symbolism of electing a viruntly anti-American politician is not good for Ireland.

Mary McAleese has served with the highest standards as our president. Her gentleness, her sublety (she recently declined an invitation to march in New York's St. Patrick's Day parade because gay groups are forbidden from marching) and her class have made her, and the presidency, a great example of what Ireland stands for. As both gay and Irish, I owe David Norris a lot of respect and admiration, but I don't owe him my vote.