Wednesday, June 22, 2011

Tipp's new casino


I'm all in favour of the new casino resort in Two Mile Borris, which is just outside of Thurles, the town I call home. I think the criticisms of the project are entirely unconvincing. Broadsheet.ie referred to it as a "stunningly tasteless, hubristic metaphor". This attempt at associating the casino with the reckless gambling of The Bankers is cheap and absurd, however light-hearted it may be. Without this kind of large-scale investment, how will we pull ourselves out of the mess we're in, anyway?

This kind of venture represents Ireland's future. Manufacturing will never survive here, and so that focus will shift to the service industry. Some have complained that it means more "low grade, minimum wage jobs" (as a commenter on Broadsheet remarked). This might be true, but those kind of jobs already exist. Many people are glad of them, many people will be glad of the employment opportunities offered by this new project. 

There are concerns about the effect this may have on culture and environment, too, but all of them seem wildly overstated.  People already gamble every single day in this country, online, in bookmakers or in the small-size casinos in some of the bigger cities. It's not as though there is no gambling culture as things stand. The notion that this behaviour somehow becomes sleazy or corrupting only when it takes place in a Vegas-style casino is nonsense. In terms of visual pollution, the buildings that comprise the casino are not at all tacky, and even the White House replica looks attractive and is actually a tribute to it's designer, James Hoban, who was born and raised in Kilkenny, rather than a gaudy imitation. 

Worries about the riskiness of this venture are more reasonable, but I think the fact that the site is situtated equidistant from all the major cities in the Republic is compelling evidence that this resort will attract the necessary number of consumers. Many tourists already come to Tipperary to visit the famous Rock of Cashel, anyway. Overall, I'm just very excited. Things like this don't really happen in Tipperary. Most of the people here I talk to, from my 20 year old friends to my elderly grandparents are also very excited. This is good news

Saturday, June 11, 2011

Should We Draw Mohammed?

The Red Writers are a collective of far left bloggers, and I've been enjoying their blog for the past few weeks. I disagree entirely with almost every single sentiment uttered over there, but it's definitely food for thought.

In the posting "Should We Draw Mohammed?", from all the way back in June 2010, I found much objectionable content. It's basically yet more of the kind of logical gymnastics, seemingly willful hypocrisy and wrongheaded apologetics I've come to expect from the anti-war Left:
In short, Muslims in Europe are under attack from the far-right who use "defending free speech" as a tool to spread reactionary propaganda such as Geert Wilders anti-Islamic film Fitna.
The narrative surrounding Geert Wilders as some kind of extremist right-winger is bizarre. This man, and his party, are standing up for gay rights and women's rights. Their stance on immigration is actually fairly mainstream and his rhetoric is not at all hateful. This doesn't seem like the behaviour of a "proto-fascist". It doesn't matter whether Fitna is true or not, the fact the the people who provided funding for the project had to create a front group for 'fear of repraisal' is the truly shameful thing here. The fact that Wilders made a movie criticising Islam in the Netherlands is, in fact, very brave and he should be applauded. Theo van Gogh was shot 8 times on the morning of November 2nd, 2004 in Amsterdam for directing a movie called Submission which is critical of Islam. He was also stabbed in the chest (after his assasin attempted to decapitate him) and attached to the knife was a note threatening the life of Ayaan Hirsi Ali, the writer of Submission and a Dutch parliament member, who later had to flee the country for her own safety. Hirsi Ali is an inspirational and courageous woman, she hardly seems like any kind of anti-immigrant fascist (she's an immigrant herself).

The issue is, in fact, black and white. The economy of a small European country was threatenend and its' embassasies attacked because of some cartoons. The governments of Muslim countries (namely Turkey and Iran) reprimanded the Danish Prime Minister for not breaking his own country's laws and censoring the cartoons. The history of conflict between Islam and the West is not an excuse for this kind of hysterical reaction, and the Left's apologetics for it is disgusting. Every bit as disgusting as the deafening silence from these same people when the Iranian head of state offered money in his own name to suborn the murder of Salman Rushdie for the grand crime of writing a work of fiction. It's the same kind of misguided apologetics, and it's just as outrageous this time around.

On the broader point, there is a critical misunderstanding here. Many anti-war types believe the existence of anti-Western sentiment is all to do with American crimes in the Middle East and in other 'Muslim lands'. It's true that many US politicians are guilty of heinous war crimes (Henry Kissinger being Exhibit A), but this does not explain Islamism. The anti-war Left is happy to think that the U.S. invited the attack on 9/11, or at least that it was understandable as some kind of counter-attack. All attacks by Muslims on the West are understandable as some kind of resistance, it would seem. But they're missing the point. Radicalised Muslims regularly kill one another in Iraq with suicide bombings, acid is thrown in the faces of unveiled women in Waziristan and homosexual teenagers are hanged in Iran. Egyptian Coptic Christians are attacked in Cairo, honour killings are routine in places like Syria and Jordan, etc., etc. In what way can the West to be blamed for this behaviour? The fact is that radical Muslims behave in the way they do because of a fanatical belief in a religion.

Iraqi Kurdistan could rightly be called a concentration camp on top and a mass grave underneath during the reign of the Hussein crime family, but the people there have shown themselves to be mature and enthusiastic in working to build a new Iraq. No brutality was spared them, and yet they are not destructive in their behavior. If it were true that people naturally react to 'oppression' with suicide bombings and hysterical riots, why is this not the case with the Kurds?

The logic is all wrong, the apologetics have to stop. What's more, the Left in the US and especially in Europe should be on the side of the socialist movements in the Middle East that are standing up to Islamic fascism and fighting for the rights of women, the right to free speech, etc. Those are the natural allies of the Left, I would have thought. But instead, they've seemingly decided to attach themselves to a clutch of hysterical religious fanatics ... because, hey, at least someone is standing up to Yankee capitalism, right?

Sunday, February 20, 2011

The Dáil really needs Ivana Bacik

I disagree with Ms. Bacik on issues like multiculturalism and some gender issues, but I think she would be perfect for the Dáil. She has shown a committment to standing up for equality and fairness (particularly for gays and lesbians, but also for immigrants) and for common sense. Her campaign for legalised abortion in this country is incredibly important. She appears to be indefatigueable and her patience when faced with bigots or ignorant folks is admirable. I hope she manages to take a seat in Dun Laoghaire next Friday.


Saturday, February 19, 2011

Oh, there ain't no other way ...

I have to say, I'm completely in love with Lady Gaga's new single, Born This Way. It was so massively hyped online, I was half-expecting to be disappointed. But she delivered an excellent sound, with some great lyrics about diversity and all that fluffy stuff. I also like that it's probably the first number one single (#1 all over the word, it seems) that directly references gays and lesbians and even transgender people. Gaga's talk about birthing a new race of people incapable of hate, and her Grammy entrance encased in a giant egg all seems ridiculous if harmless. But I do agree with what she said in a recent interview that music doesn't always have to be sexy or deep and subtle. Sometimes feel good anthems like Born This Way are a breath of fresh air.

Also, this video basically sums up why I love Lady Gaga so much. Everyone keeps ripping on her for being heavily influenced by Madonna or whatever, but Ms. Cicone would never have made this phonecall. Moreover, her songs would never have inspired such devotion from a 10 year old. Gaga's songs are accessible and she seems to genuinely care about her fans.

Compulsory Irish is important and worthwhile

My good friend Derwin Brennan has a blog post up about the recent Irish language protests in which he attempts to dispel what he perceives as myths about compulsory Gaeilge. I disagree, and I think Irish serves an important function in this country and that its status as compulsory is vital.

First of all, I think it's important to note that we don't educate people solely to increase their potential earnings in whatever career they end up in. It's not about turning pupils into money-making machines. The people who make arguments that claim that Irish should not be compulsory because there's little chance of using it in any career outside of teaching and working for TG4 seem to neglect this fact. If it was the case that we only educated people so that they can generate wealth, we wouldn't have compulsory English literature classes or compulsory advanced mathematics in the Senior cycle of secondary education. Of course, preparing pupils for successful careers is a function of education, but it's just one function, and certainly not the most important function of going to school. Whether or not pupils will use Irish to earn a living, the fact is they are learning a beautiful, complex language and that, in and of itself, is worthwhile as learning any language is useful in terms of increased linguistic understanding and further knowledge about language in general. It's also fairly well accepted that learning a language from a young age can help in the accquisition of other languages.

Moreover, there is an important cultural dimension. Derwin dismisses this argument, claiming that to be Irish and to be speak the Irish language are different things. I agree, one's Irishness is not conditioned on one's ability to speak the native language. This would be absurd, and would exclude the vast majority of Irish people, both on this island and in the diaspora. However, this seems like a red herring. No one says that to be Irish, one must speak Irish. The point, rather, is that the Irish identity and yes, Irish culture has strong links with Gaeilge.

Like it or not, our ancestors spoke this language. They wrote poems lamenting the gradual loss of the language under the oppressive Penal Laws and suppression by a colonial power. I think it's important that the reason we no longer speak Irish is because of violent oppression. The people of Ireland did not choose to abandon the language because English was just handier. In fact, many people fought and died for the right of the Irish to speak this language and I think, for this reason, it deserves at least some respect and certainly the successor state of that struggle has a duty to promote and preserve the language. That oppression and struggle characterises Irish people in a significant way.; it's ingrained in our psyche. How could it not be? The Irish diaspora is so huge precisely because so many were forced to immigrate as a result of that oppression. That's why we celebrate the 1916 rising and study that history in primary school. Learning Irish helps us to interact with that history, to better understand the struggle for Irish liberty. Laments like Mo Ghile Mear lose something important when translated.

The Irish language clearly plays an important role in this country. The kind of English we speak, Hiberno-English is influenced by Irish grammar, vocabulary and pronounciation. Irish is on all road signs, Rail and Luas announcements. People speak Irish every day in the Gaeltacht, at school or at social gatherings organised by groups like Conradh na Gaeilge. Our constitution is written in Irish. Whenever there's an ambiguity in the text, the Irish interpretation is accepted. If Irish is no longer compulsory at advanced levels, we end up in the situation where citizens are not being prepared to properly and fully understand their own constitution. Our national anthem is always performed as Gaeilge. Irish is recognised as an official language of the European Union. The recent leader's debate on TG4, where all 3 potential Taoisigh showcased their fluency, was by far the best debate so far and was watched by around 140,000 people. Any notion that the language is dead seems like nonsense as far as I'm concerned.

As I've already explained the state has a duty to promote and preserve the language. It promotes the language by ensuring that people can interact with the state, by and large, in Irish if they so choose. The compulsory nature of the Irish language in secondary schools is important to preserve the language. I acknowledge that we're not doing the best job of teaching Irish, that we've fallen short in putting together a good curriculum that properly allows pupils to enjoy learning the language and to become competent in it. However, I know that putting together the best and most effective curriciulum is difficult. Irish is so important that the failings of the Dept. of Education should not lead to it's demise. The compulsory status is a safety net.

Let's work on improving the standard of Irish education and better providing for pupils to access all of the cultural and educational benefits of the language. It'll be difficult, of course, but it's better than just giving up.

Wednesday, January 5, 2011

Kesha goes too far

It's generally very hard to shock me, especially considering I enjoy things like South Park and tasteless internet memes, but Kesha's referencing of serial rapist and killer Jeffrey Dahmer in a pop song is a step too far ... It's kind of funny that she actually 'went there', but it still seems to be much too tasteless for my liking.

Check it out:

Monday, December 27, 2010

Does David Norris represent Irish attitudes on foreign policy?

“Behold the Tolerant Irish!”, so the headlines around the world will read if David Norris is elected president in 2011. At least, that's what he wants you to think. He believes that media around the world will proclaim Ireland to be an impressively accepting society after his election as the first ever openly gay head of state. Norris believes that the 'good press' generated by his election will somehow create the political capital necessary to secure the best possible reputation for this country. This is not just some off the cuff remark by Norris. He has stated it over and over again – in interviews on television, radio, and recently in his address to DCU students. The fact that he has made the novelty factor of his sexuality an important point in his campaign is typically inapropriate and characteristically frivolous. Furthermore, I believe that Mr. Norris is wrong in this prediction. The headlines in the US, for example, will not glorify Irish tolerance, but will focus on the vicious anti-American sentiments that litter his political career.
In 2005, Norris declared the United States government to be a “criminal regime”, spreading its' “plague” all over the world. He made these comments on the floor of the Seanad, in his capacity as a senator. I'm fairly certain that this kind of animus directed at the American people (those who elect this “criminal regime”) won't go down so well. What's more, his sympathy for terrorist organisations like Hamas is worrying. While the American governement, which runs a free and tolerant society, is “criminal” in Norris' view, Hamas, an organisation that murders members of the oppostion, seeks the destruction of Israel (and, as a matter of fact, the execution of all homosexuals) is the “legitimate government” of Gaza. Most Irish people, I would imagine, are not supportive of organisations that wish to see the Jewish state in ruins. Most people would describe Hamas' very existance as being shameful. Not David Norris, though. For him, the only thing that is “shameful” is the EU's boycott of this extremist organisation. Why someone with such a strong record on defending civil liberties and standing up for human rights in this country has an ounce of sympathy for reactionary extremists is baffling.

When he visited DCU last year, I asked David Norris about his anti-American track record, and pressed him on whether or not he still stands by his assertion of the criminality of the Bush administration. "Yes" he replied. He went on, in typical unseriousness, to say he couldn't possibly be anti-American because he liked Bugs Bunny. Then he asked me about Guantanamo Bay. using it as some kind proof of Bush's criminal status. President Obama has kept Guantanamo Bay open, and has resumed military tribunals there. In fact, Obama has virtually continued all of the Bush anti-terror policies. But Norris remains silent on this, instead showering Obama with praise. There is a blatent inconsistency here, one that highlights Norris' childishness and naivity on matters of foreign policy. Bush is proud of America's foreign policy, so he is hated. Obama offers petty platitudes in the form of apologies and regret for Iraq, but continues all of Bush's policies anyway, and he is adored. Is this really the behaviour of a man of principles when it comes to these important issues? Of course not.

I realise the presidency will not give David Norris an opportunity to enact any policies or even to impact on political discourse in any meaningful way. Even if it did, Ireland is a tiny country, our foreign policy largely does not matter. It is true, however, that the presidency is entirely symbolic (the constitution doesn't even nominally vest any executive power in the president). Given that the presidency is supposed to be representative of Irish attitudes and values to the rest of the world, the symbolism of electing a viruntly anti-American politician is not good for Ireland.

Mary McAleese has served with the highest standards as our president. Her gentleness, her sublety (she recently declined an invitation to march in New York's St. Patrick's Day parade because gay groups are forbidden from marching) and her class have made her, and the presidency, a great example of what Ireland stands for. As both gay and Irish, I owe David Norris a lot of respect and admiration, but I don't owe him my vote.

Politics

After a long break, I think I'm going to give this blogging thing another shot. This time, I want to focus mainly on politics, as that seems to be the subject that most compels me to writing. As such, I think it's important to outline my general political opinions and leanings.

I think labels are important. They may be unhelpful sometimes but mostly they are imporant as a means of summarising the general political opinions of someone. I identify myself as a social democrat, someone who believes passionately in democracy and freedom, but seeks to reform capitalism in ways that align it more to the goals of social justice, while still maintaining the capitalist mode of production. Socially, I, of course, support equality for gays and lesbians. I think the fact that abortion is illegal in this country in the year 2010 is to our great shame. I support the legalisation of all drugs, but not because I believe everyone can do with their own bodies as they please. Hardcore drugs are enormously harmful, not just to the users but to their families and friends and to the general good order of society. That said, prohibition just is not working. The War on Drugs is a catastrophic failure. It is time to get serious about the issue, legalise drugs so we can enforce some kind of regulation on them and bring drug addicts into the system where we can work at rehabilitating them, rather than criminalising them and keeping them at a distance. I detest any influence of religion on policy. Religion is harmful in all its' guises, and the less influence it has over anyone, the better.

I'm also a neoconservative. I think labels are important, but sometimes they can be misleading. The term "neoconservative" has a long and storied history, but when I use it I mean to convey the presently understood meaning of that term. Moreover, a neocon is someone who is literally willing to declare war on the status quo and can hardly be considered a conservative.

Often, people are confused at my left-leaning fiscal and social opinions and my hawkish outlook on matters of foreign policy. This apparently seems contradictory to some people, which surprised me at first. The Left usually stands up for the oppressed, stands against fascism ... right? As such, it only makes sense that the goals of the Left would be a liberated Iraq and a free Afghanistan, etc. I soon learned this was not the case at all. The anti-war Left protested against intervention in Bosnia, when thousands of Ethnic Muslims were being cleansed for the depraved fantasy of a Greater Serbia. That same movement would have left Iraq as the personal property of a deranged criminal family, one guilty of genocide. That is their legacy, and they're welcome to it. I believe that Western power (specifically the power of the US and her allies) is there to be used, and should be used to shape the world in a way that promotes democracy and freedom. It is not a coincidence that free countries do not suffer famines or political violence. Moreover, if the US does not act to shape the world, someone else will. I would rather it be the US, government , which runs a free and tolerant society, than fascist, extremist governments like Iran or North Korea.

This is just a terse summary of my opinions, just laying the groundwork for future writings in which I intend to further explore my own opinions and examine the opposing arguments.

Wednesday, September 2, 2009

"Meditational Field"


The name of my blog (and this is the third time I've re-named it), "Meditational Field", is the title of Susumu Hirasawa's amazing opening piece for the wonderful and exceptionally bizarre Satoshi Kon movie Paprika.

It's not very meaningful, it just sounds cool.

Irish embassy response on Budapest pride parade

I e-mailed the Irish embassy in Budapest to express my disappointment over our ambassador's not being included among the representatives of Australia, Canada, the Czech Republic, France, Germany, the Netherlands, Norway, Slovenia, South Africa, Spain, Sweden, the United Kingdom and the United States in issuing a statement of support for the upcoming pride parade in Hungary's capital.

This morning, I got this reply:

Dear Mr Gormley,

Thank you for your email of 31 August 2009 to the Embassy of Ireland in respect of the upcoming Gay Pride Parade in Budapest. For reasons of timing, it was not possible for us to associate ourselves with the statement made by a number of other Embassies in Budapest before the text issued on 28 August. We of course share our colleagues' hope that this weekend's march will be allowed to proceed peacefully and not be marred by the violence seen in recent years.

Yours sincerely,


Dermot McGauran

Chargé d'affaires a.i.


I'm glad to hear the Irish embassy supports the rights and dignity of those in Budapest. Also happy to know that it was just logistics, rather than deliberate avoidance or ignorance, that's behind Ireland's absence among the list of countries issuing that joint statement.